a good year movie review

• Share full article

Advertisement

Supported by

Movie Review | 'A Good Year'

Stopping to Smell the Vintner’s Bouquet

By Stephen Holden

• Nov. 10, 2006

“A Good Year,” an innocuous, feel-good movie that reunites Russell Crowe with the director Ridley Scott, is a far cry from the triumphant metallic stomp of “Gladiator,” their previous collaboration. A sun-dappled romantic diversion, which one British critic has already dismissed as “tourist gastro-porn,” “A Good Year” is a three-P movie: pleasant, pretty and predictable. One might add piddling.

If nothing else, this celebration of French food and wine, adapted from Peter Mayle’s 2004 novel, will whet an appetite for consuming “the nectar that is incapable of lying,” as the film’s dissipated philosopher of epicurean delights calls the product of his estate in Provence. Viewers are advised to make a reservation at an upscale French restaurant immediately after seeing the film or risk going home feeling deprived.

For Mr. Crowe, whose public image took a hit last year when he threw a telephone at a desk clerk in a New York hotel and later pleaded guilty to assault, “A Good Year” looks like a calculated charm offensive by an actor not known for his courtly manners. His character, Max Skinner, a ferociously aggressive London bond trader who inherits a small vineyard from his Uncle Henry (Albert Finney) and quickly mellows into a rich, happy, bon vivant, is the sort of role usually taken by Hugh Grant.

Mr. Crowe, estimable actor that he is, gives what may be his cheeriest screen performance. But is he charming? Let’s just say that both Grants (Hugh and the ghost of Cary) can rest comfortably. Mr. Crowe is not unlikable. But as for visceral charm, there are only flashes here and there.

For Mr. Scott “A Good Year” is one of his periodic palate cleansers. Amid his outpouring of would-be blockbusters — “Gladiator,” “Hannibal,” “Black Hawk Down” and “Kingdom of Heaven” — all released since 2000, only one other film, “Matchstick Men,” qualifies as a breather from a schedule that suggests the directorial equivalent of training for a heavyweight bout.

The blandness of “A Good Year” isn’t the fault of Mr. Scott, who pumps the film full of visual energy and gorgeous scenery, but of its screenwriter, Marc Klein (“Serendipity”). You keep waiting for some witty banter, but except for scattered remarks and Max’s slapstick tumble into an empty swimming pool, there isn’t much comedy.

The inevitable romance, when it arrives in the person of a French bistro owner, Fanny (Marion Cotillard), whom he covets at first sight, is a half-baked affair in which her chilly resistance thaws faster than ice cream in a microwave.

The movie begins, in its own coy language, “a few vintages ago” with a scene of Max as a boy (Freddie Highmore) frolicking on the estate of his snobbish, bibulous uncle. As this old man dispenses sartorial advice to his nephew, the cocky wunderkind beats him at chess. The story then shoots ahead “many vintages later” to catch the grown-up Max, now a preening Master of the Universe, as he spits fire in his London brokerage house and leads his “lab rats,” as he calls his troops, in an unscrupulous maneuver that nets his company tens of millions of dollars.

Word arrives that Max’s once-beloved Uncle Henry, with whom he lost touch years earlier, has died, leaving no will. As his uncle’s closest surviving relative, Max stands to inherit the estate, La Siroque, which he visits, determined to make a quick sale based on the advice of his best friend, Charlie Willis (Tom Hollander), a London real-estate agent. But once he arrives in France where the sun is brighter, the grapes tastier and the women more pliable, ooh la la! Before the property can be sold, it needs repairs, especially the tennis court, and he lingers there and begins to rediscover the simple pleasures of those halcyon childhood summers.

But even in paradise Max is prickly and insensitive. He repeatedly tramples on the feelings of his uncle’s winemaker (Didier Bourdon) and shouts “Lance Armstrong!” while driving past a group of French cyclists. Nice guy.

Out of the blue a young woman from California, Christie Roberts (Abbie Cornish), shows up and announces she is Uncle Henry’s illegitimate daughter. If her claim is true, she, not Max, would get La Siroque, whose value suddenly diminishes after a wine-growing expert tests the vines and pronounces restoration of the vineyard to its former glory impossible.

With two pretty women lurking around the premises, you might expect a rivalry to develop, but the movie barely considers the possibility. Failing that, you might expect Max and Christie to wage a cutthroat battle for ownership of the estate. But Christie, an oenophile from Napa Valley, is primarily interested in knowing more about her father. Ms. Cornish (the young Australian actress who was so gripping in “Somersault”) exudes a palpable discomfort in her confusing, underwritten role.

“A Good Year” is the movie equivalent of poring over a glossy brochure for a luxury vacation you could never afford while a roughneck salesman (Mr. Crowe) who imagines he has class harangues you to hurry up and make a decision about taking the tour. My advice is to resist the pitch.

The movie is rated PG-13 (Parents strongly cautioned). It has some strong language and one mild sex scene.

A GOOD YEAR

Opens today nationwide.

Directed by Ridley Scott; written by Marc Klein, based on the novel by Peter Mayle; director of photography, Philippe Le Sourd; edited by Dody Dorn; music by Marc Streitenfeld; production designer, Sonja Klaus; produced by Mr. Scott; released by Fox 2000 Pictures. Running time: 117 minutes.

WITH: Russell Crowe (Max Skinner), Albert Finney (Uncle Henry), Marion Cotillard (Fanny), Abbie Cornish (Christie Roberts), Tom Hollander (Charlie Willis), Freddie Highmore (Young Max) and Didier Bourdon (Francis Duflot).

• Cast & crew
• User reviews

A Good Year

A British investment broker inherits his uncle's chateau and vineyard in Provence, where he spent much of his childhood. He discovers a new laid-back lifestyle as he tries to renovate the es... Read all A British investment broker inherits his uncle's chateau and vineyard in Provence, where he spent much of his childhood. He discovers a new laid-back lifestyle as he tries to renovate the estate to be sold. A British investment broker inherits his uncle's chateau and vineyard in Provence, where he spent much of his childhood. He discovers a new laid-back lifestyle as he tries to renovate the estate to be sold.

• Ridley Scott
• Peter Mayle
• Russell Crowe
• Abbie Cornish
• Albert Finney
• 272 User reviews
• 145 Critic reviews
• 47 Metascore
• 1 win & 2 nominations

Top cast 64

• Max Skinner

• Christie Roberts

• Uncle Henry

• Fanny Chenal

• 20-Something Beauty

• Bert the Doorman

• Newscaster #1
• Newscaster #2

• Maitre D'

• Charlie Willis
• Rental Car Employee

• Gemma's Friend
• All cast & crew
• Production, box office & more at IMDbPro

More like this

Did you know

• Trivia According to director/producer Sir Ridley Scott , every scene of the film (except the London scenes) was shot within eight minutes of his home in Provence, where he has been living for 15 years.
• Goofs When Max is playing tennis at La Siroque, the sound that the tennis racquets make does not correspond with the type of old racquets they have. The sound is from a modern tennis racquet.

Uncle Henry Skinner : You'll come to see that a man learns nothing from winning. The act of losing, however, can elicit great wisdom. Not least of which is, uh... how much more enjoyable it is to win. It's inevitable to lose now and again. The trick is not to make a habit of it.

• Connections Featured in Friday Night with Jonathan Ross: Episode #11.6 (2006)
• Soundtracks Lounge Lizard Written and Performed by Joe Lervold Courtesy of Marc Ferrari / Mastersource

User reviews 272

• Nov 10, 2006
• Does anyone know what exact model his orange/brown glasses are? Thanks!
• What does the Fanny say to Max at the pool?
• Is it true that lavender keeps scorpions away?
• November 10, 2006 (United States)
• United States
• United Kingdom
• Stream A Good Year officially on Disney+ Hotstar Indonesia
• Mùa Tình Yêu
• Chateau la Canorgue, Bonnieux, Vaucluse, France (Chateau La Siroque)
• Fox 2000 Pictures
• Scott Free Productions
• Ingenious Film Partners
• See more company credits at IMDbPro
• $35,000,000 (estimated)
• Nov 12, 2006
• $42,269,923

Technical specs

• Runtime 1 hour 57 minutes
• Dolby Digital

Related news

Contribute to this page.

• See more gaps
• Learn more about contributing

More to explore

Recently viewed.

Log in or sign up for Rotten Tomatoes

Trouble logging in?

By continuing, you agree to the Privacy Policy and the Terms and Policies , and to receive email from the Fandango Media Brands .

By creating an account, you agree to the Privacy Policy and the Terms and Policies , and to receive email from Rotten Tomatoes and to receive email from the Fandango Media Brands .

By creating an account, you agree to the Privacy Policy and the Terms and Policies , and to receive email from Rotten Tomatoes.

Email not verified

Let's keep in touch.

Sign up for the Rotten Tomatoes newsletter to get weekly updates on:

• Upcoming Movies and TV shows
• Rotten Tomatoes Podcast
• Media News + More

By clicking "Sign Me Up," you are agreeing to receive occasional emails and communications from Fandango Media (Fandango, Vudu, and Rotten Tomatoes) and consenting to Fandango's Privacy Policy and Terms and Policies . Please allow 10 business days for your account to reflect your preferences.

OK, got it!

• About Rotten Tomatoes®
• Login/signup

Movies in theaters

• Opening This Week
• Top Box Office
• Coming Soon to Theaters
• Certified Fresh Movies

Movies at Home

• Fandango at Home
• Prime Video
• Most Popular Streaming Movies
• What to Watch New

Certified fresh picks

• 73% Blink Twice Link to Blink Twice
• 96% Strange Darling Link to Strange Darling
• 86% Between the Temples Link to Between the Temples

New TV Tonight

• 96% Only Murders in the Building: Season 4
• 92% The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power: Season 2
• 95% Terminator Zero: Season 1
• 68% Kaos: Season 1
• 83% City of God: The Fight Rages On: Season 1
• -- Here Come the Irish: Season 1
• -- K-Pop Idols: Season 1
• -- Horror's Greatest: Season 1
• -- After Baywatch: Moment in the Sun: Season 1

Most Popular TV on RT

• 100% Dark Winds: Season 2
• 92% Bad Monkey: Season 1
• 78% Star Wars: The Acolyte: Season 1
• 100% Pachinko: Season 2
• Best TV Shows
• Most Popular TV

Certified fresh pick

• 92% The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power: Season 2 Link to The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power: Season 2
• All-Time Lists
• Binge Guide
• Comics on TV
• Five Favorite Films
• Video Interviews
• Weekend Box Office
• Weekly Ketchup
• What to Watch

The Best Shows on Amazon Prime Video to Watch Right Now (August 2024)

100 Best Netflix Series To Watch Right Now (August 2024)

What to Watch: In Theaters and On Streaming

Awards Tour

TV Premiere Dates 2024

Your Full List of All Upcoming Marvel Movies — With Key Details!

• Trending on RT
• Beetlejuice Beetlejuice
• Rings of Power S2 First Reviews
• Venice Film Festival
• Fall Horror Movie Preview

A Good Year Reviews

A Good Year is a light snack of comfort-food cinema and Scott’s only comedy— not that there are a huge amount of laughs.

Full Review | Apr 23, 2024

It's a film from which you'd expect the moon, the stars and the sun. What with an actor like Crowe and a director like Scott. Disappointingly, the talented duo gives you the most wishy-washy film of the year.

Full Review | Original Score: 1/4 | Jan 23, 2019

It's not so much A Good Year as A Good Yawn (if not A Full-on Nap).

Full Review | Aug 22, 2018

Full Review | Original Score: 6/10 | Feb 9, 2011

Predictable but pleasant movie for teens and up.

Full Review | Original Score: 3/5 | Jan 1, 2011

Russell Crowe brings to bear his now-familiar acting tics in a not-so-tender romance by director Ridley Scott.

Full Review | Original Score: C- | Apr 24, 2009

[Russel Crowe's] supply of quips and pratfalls is inexhaustible, even when he's trapped at the bottom of a swimming pool surrounded by peat and dry leaves. Alas, he escapes.

Full Review | Original Score: 2/5 | Jun 8, 2008

Under the Tuscan Sun for men

Full Review | Original Score: 2.5/5 | Mar 22, 2007

Forget that this is a film about a man's epiphany about what's important in life, and enjoy it for its lighthearted moments, slapstick comedy, but most of all its divine locations.

Full Review | Original Score: 3/5 | Dec 30, 2006

Full Review | Original Score: 2/5 | Dec 30, 2006

Crowe has located his funnybone again in a conventional but engaging romantic comedy ...

Full Review | Original Score: 2.5/4 | Dec 7, 2006

This Gallic tourist-porn feels as stale as yesterday's baguette.

Full Review | Dec 1, 2006

'Look Homeward, Gladiator' hints at new dimensions of warmth and heart in Russell Crowe and Ridley Scott. They're not there yet, but they're headed in the right direction.

Full Review | Original Score: 2.5/4 | Nov 24, 2006

A Good Year is, structurally, nothing more than a rickety assembly of the creakiest cinematic clichés.

Full Review | Nov 20, 2006

Ultimately, though, the odd witty line and scads of eye candy can’t compensate for a lack of dramatic dynamism or a cast that just isn’t very funny.

Full Review | Nov 18, 2006

It's so goddamned cute you almost want to puke, but you don't. This is the most charming movie of the year, and it comes within an inch of being too sweet to stand, but it doesn't get there.

Full Review | Original Score: 4/5 | Nov 18, 2006

Does not translate into a good film.

Full Review | Original Score: C | Nov 16, 2006

The course A Good Year takes feels like it's on rails: there's only one possible destination and only one way to get there.

Full Review | Original Score: 2.5/4 | Nov 15, 2006

Scott's film is like a reproduction of things he's seen in romantic comedies over the years with no idea why they're there.

Full Review | Original Score: 2.5/5 | Nov 15, 2006

Alternately, you could do your laundry, which would be just as exciting and possibly more dramatic.

Full Review | Original Score: C- | Nov 15, 2006

Common Sense Media

Movie & TV reviews for parents

• For Parents
• For Educators
• Our Work and Impact

Or browse by category:

• Movie Reviews
• Best Movie Lists
• Best Movies on Netflix, Disney+, and More

Common Sense Selections for Movies

50 Modern Movies All Kids Should Watch Before They're 12

• Best TV Lists
• Best TV Shows on Netflix, Disney+, and More
• Common Sense Selections for TV
• Video Reviews of TV Shows

Best Kids' Shows on Disney+

Best Kids' TV Shows on Netflix

• Book Reviews
• Best Book Lists
• Common Sense Selections for Books

8 Tips for Getting Kids Hooked on Books

50 Books All Kids Should Read Before They're 12

• Game Reviews
• Best Game Lists

Common Sense Selections for Games

• Video Reviews of Games

Nintendo Switch Games for Family Fun

• Podcast Reviews
• Best Podcast Lists

Common Sense Selections for Podcasts

Parents' Guide to Podcasts

• App Reviews
• Best App Lists

Social Networking for Teens

Gun-Free Action Game Apps

Reviews for AI Apps and Tools

• YouTube Channel Reviews
• YouTube Kids Channels by Topic

Parents' Ultimate Guide to YouTube Kids

YouTube Kids Channels for Gamers

• Preschoolers (2-4)
• Little Kids (5-7)
• Big Kids (8-9)
• Pre-Teens (10-12)
• Teens (13+)
• Screen Time
• Social Media
• Online Safety
• Identity and Community

How to Help Kids Build Character Strengths with Quality Media

• Family Tech Planners
• Digital Skills
• All Articles
• Latino Culture
• Black Voices
• Asian Stories
• Native Narratives
• LGBTQ+ Pride
• Best of Diverse Representation List

Multicultural Books

YouTube Channels with Diverse Representations

Podcasts with Diverse Characters and Stories

A good year.

• Common Sense Says
• Parents Say 4 Reviews
• Kids Say 0 Reviews

Common Sense Media Review

By Jane Boursaw , based on child development research. How do we rate?

Predictable but pleasant movie for teens and up.

Parents Need to Know

Parents need to know that main character Max is selfish and greedy and doesn't care who he hurts to get ahead. His whole life is about making money, and he revels in the fact that he's good at it, even though people hate him. Wine and drinking figure prominently in the storyline, and the romance between two characters…

Why Age 13+?

Sanyo; Max relies heavily on his Treo.

Wine, drinking, and getting drunk figure prominently in the storyline.

Pretty mild: "Hell," "ass," "bullocks."

Romance and flirting between characters, sexual banter, bedroom scene, female ch

Crazy driving while talking on a cell phone. Max falls into an empty pool and ca

Any Positive Content?

Max is greedy and selfish and will walk over anyone to get ahead. People hate hi

Products & Purchases

Drinking, drugs & smoking.

Did you know you can flag iffy content? Adjust limits for Drinking, Drugs & Smoking in your kid's entertainment guide.

Did you know you can flag iffy content? Adjust limits for Language in your kid's entertainment guide.

Sex, Romance & Nudity

Romance and flirting between characters, sexual banter, bedroom scene, female characters in tight dresses with cleavage.

Did you know you can flag iffy content? Adjust limits for Sex, Romance & Nudity in your kid's entertainment guide.

Violence & Scariness

Crazy driving while talking on a cell phone. Max falls into an empty pool and can't get out. Fanny floods it with water while he's in there.

Did you know you can flag iffy content? Adjust limits for Violence & Scariness in your kid's entertainment guide.

Positive Messages

Max is greedy and selfish and will walk over anyone to get ahead. People hate him, and he relishes it.

Parents need to know that main character Max is selfish and greedy and doesn't care who he hurts to get ahead. His whole life is about making money, and he revels in the fact that he's good at it, even though people hate him. Wine and drinking figure prominently in the storyline, and the romance between two characters gets a little steamy (they flirt, tear each other's clothes off, and end up in bed), but it's nothing teens haven't seen before. That said, most teens probably won't be too interested in this one, since it focuses on more mid-life issues. To stay in the loop on more movies like this, you can sign up for weekly Family Movie Night emails .

Where to Watch

Videos and photos.

Parent and Kid Reviews

• Parents say (4)

Based on 4 parent reviews

Beautifully made, well casted, excellent plot

Beautiful scenery, predictable plot., what's the story.

Max Skinner ( Russell Crowe ) is a rich, selfish, high-powered London stock trader. He's not interested in slowing down -- until his Uncle Henry ( Albert Finney ) dies and leaves him a beautiful country chateau and vineyard in France. Max spent many happy summers there as a child, learning about life and winemaking from his wise uncle. Max hasn't been there in 10 years, but now he's forced to take time off from work to handle his uncle's estate. He plans to quickly sell the chateau and return home. But Max misses his plane and gets stuck in France, dealing with all those pesky, warm memories. Before long, he starts to soften, but he's pulled in both directions. He enjoys re-living childhood memories, but he's not quite ready to give up his luxurious London life. Complicating things are feisty Fanny (Marion Cotillard) and Henry's illegitimate daughter, Kristy (Abbie Cornish), both of whom have Max thinking about his future.

Is It Any Good?

We've seen this passable movie before in various incarnations -- most notably Under the Tuscan Sun , with Diane Lane in the Russell Crowe part, discovering herself in the Italian countryside. Consequently, there are no surprises here. We know what's going to happen, and we know pretty much how it's going to happen.

That said, A Good Year is a nice production (with beautiful, sun-washed landscapes) by Ridley Scott , a great director who makes audiences care about his characters, even if everyone does know how things are going to turn out. Crowe does the bad-boy-turned-good role well, and manages to keep the pace moving along fairly well. All in all, this movie is a pleasant enough way to spend a couple of hours if you're not looking for anything earth-shattering.

Talk to Your Kids About ...

Families can talk about what's important in life: money or family? Max has lived his life solely for himself and his own gain -- how has that affected his quality of life? How can people balance earning a good living with having time for friends and family? Is it possible to do both? What kinds of sacrifices are needed? What does Max learn in the course of the movie?

Movie Details

• In theaters : November 10, 2006
• On DVD or streaming : February 27, 2007
• Cast : Albert Finney , Marion Cotillard , Russell Crowe
• Director : Ridley Scott
• Inclusion Information : Female actors
• Studio : Twentieth Century Fox
• Genre : Drama
• Run time : 118 minutes
• MPAA rating : PG-13
• MPAA explanation : language and some sexual content.
• Last updated : January 19, 2024

Did we miss something on diversity?

Research shows a connection between kids' healthy self-esteem and positive portrayals in media. That's why we've added a new "Diverse Representations" section to our reviews that will be rolling out on an ongoing basis. You can help us help kids by suggesting a diversity update.

Suggest an Update

What to watch next.

Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are created by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.

A Good Year (2006): Film Review

• Christopher Connor
• November 11, 2023

Ridley Scott’s A Good Year is an underappreciated gem that shows us a different side to both the celebrated director and lead star Russell Crowe.

Ridley Scott and Russell Crowe’s partnership in the 2000s proved to be hugely successful, beginning with a Best Picture and Actor win for Gladiator and featuring the well-received American Gangster in 2007. In between these two more successful collaborations sits A Good Year , an adaptation of Peter Mayle’s 2004 novel , written for Scott. The pair were neighbours in Southern France at the time, with Scott desiring to make a fish out of water film featuring an Englishman in Provence.

A Good Year marks a departure from other Scott films , particularly of the era, coming off the back of epics like Gladiator and Kingdom of Heaven. It is one of the lighter films in his filmography, more of a straight-up comedy, something not really glimpsed again outside of The Martian ’s lighter moments. The shift in genre might account for some of the reviews for the film upon release, with it being one of the poorest-rated films in Scott’s recent filmography.

Max Skinner (Russell Crowe) is a hugely successful yet egotistical banker in the City of London who inherited his Uncle Henry’s (Albert Finney) estate in Provence. Max spent his summers there as a child, with fond memories of his doting, eccentric uncle . In recent years, however, the pair drifted apart, with the world of his uncle a far cry from the glamorous, affluent surroundings of Max’s London lifestyle. Max is initially keen to be rid of the estate as soon as possible, seeking to sell it for a handsome price.

While Max waits for the estate to be valued, including its Vineyard, he becomes smitten with the region and the local culture, and this brings back childhood memories that he has repressed. The second half of the film sees a blossoming romance between Max and the uptight and fiery Fanny Chenal (Marion Cotillard); after a series of confrontational encounters culminating with Max at the bottom of his pool, they become close.

Crowe and Cotillard’s chemistry does a lot of heavy lifting. The pair are a charming onscreen couple. Crowe captures Max’s initial frosty and world-weary nature and makes his ultimate warming and shift in character believable. Finney’s Uncle Henry, who appears via flashbacks, is charming and larger than life, the antithesis of the Max we meet earlier in the film. Tom Hollander is ever dependable as Max’s best friend Charlie who is tasked with valuing the estate and also becomes charmed by the locale.

One of the frequent critiques surrounded Russell Crowe’s comedic timing , in the years since we’ve seen him go on to have success with the likes of The Nice Guys , certainly proving his aptitude for comedic material. If Crowe isn’t as naturally funny as in The Nice Guys , his comedic timing is far from atrocious, helping keep the film together, enfusing it with a natural lightness of touch.

Perhaps one of the film’s drawbacks is the number of subplots , especially once Abbie Cornish’s Christie Roberts arrives on the scene. Christie is a self-described “wine brat” from California who claims to be Henry’s illegitimate daughter and so may have a claim to the estate. On top of this, we have a subplot involving the quality of the wine produced at the vineyard and a secret much nicer vintage made on the estate. While none of these derails the film they do cloud its focus at times, when it may have been easier to focus solely on Max and devote greater attention to his relationship with Fanny.

If still not one of Ridley Scott’s best-loved films, A Good Year justifies a re-evaluation . It is a charming romantic comedy that makes the most of its Provence setting with a fun comedic performance from Russell Crowe and a sense of charm and ease throughout. It is certainly one of the more light and sweeter films in Scott’s oeuvre, but this should not detract from its warmth and fun. Far from a total misfire, this is an under sung and rewarding film with plenty to admire.

A Good Year is now available to watch on digital and on demand.

• TAGS: Ridley Scott
• Film Festivals , Films , Venice Film Festival

Babygirl Film Review: Funny, Messy, Not So Erotic Thriller

• Clotilde Chinnici
• August 30, 2024
• Films , Must Watch

Slingshot Review: Ambiguous Space Thriller

• Joseph Tomastik

Kill the Jockey Review: More Than a Sports Drama

• August 29, 2024
• Film Festivals , Films , Must Watch , Venice Film Festival

Maria (2024) Film Review: The World is an Opera Stage

Quiet life film review: a jumbled mess.

• Serena Seghedoni

Pooja, Sir Film Review: This Woman’s Work

• Claire Fulton

LATEST POSTS

A Good Year Review

27 Oct 2006

NaN minutes

A Good Year

Ridley Scott and Russell Crowe must love the fact that their first collaboration since Gladiator couldn’t be less similar to the sword ’n’ sandal epic that revived the former’s A-list career and launched the latter’s. “They didn’t expect us to do this ,” you can almost hear them chortling. Well, there are some similarities: in both films, Russell Crowe owns a vineyard, in both he’s called Max (sort of) and, uh, that’s it. A Good Year is an entirely different bottle of plonk: rosé rather than claret, if you want to stretch a metaphor.

But while it’s all well and good to see them together again, the material doesn’t prove a fit for either. Crowe’s not attempted comedy since the disastrous Mystery, Alaska and Scott’s only previous tussle with the genre was the uneven Matchstick Men (unless you count Hannibal). The problem’s not so much that A Good Year is a comedy per se; rather that it’s one of those very gentle, breezy little comedies — you know, the kind your mum likes to watch after the Sunday roast — which require a light touch, a feel for the flippant and, ideally, an undercurrent of self-knowing absurdity to make them truly appealing. None of this is evident in either Crowe’s performance or Scott’s direction. There’s a forced jauntiness, a sense of careful calculation whizzing away behind the comedy beats, from Crowe’s intense pratfalls as Max tries to escape a derelict swimming pool, to his plummy exclamations of “bollocks” at every available opportunity.

Quite simply, Crowe and Scott are just too heavyweight. There is some novelty value in seeing Crowe squeezing his burly frame into the kind of role usually reserved for Hugh Grant or Colin Firth, but it soon wears off. The film does at least look great — who better than Scott to shoot the dusty villages and sun-snogged vistas of Bouche-du-Rhône? — and works best in its more sombre moments, as Max’s deeply buried, Freddie Highmore-shaped soul is exhumed via a series of oddly-timed flashbacks.

That A Good Year’s attempts at humour fall flat is also the fault of the script: there’s not a single good gag in here. Max’s smarmy quips, his rosbif-versus-frog sparring with shifty vintner Roussel (Didier Bourdon), the daffy maid who’s forever a breath away from squealing, “Ooh la la!”… It’s all rather flimsy, obvious stuff — these are cultural references that you need to blow the dust off. If you want a decent midlife-crisis wine comedy, stick with Sideways.

Related Articles

Movies | 23 08 2006

Movies | 28 07 2005

Screen Rant

A good year.

117 Minutes

Your changes have been saved

Email is sent

Email has already been sent

Please verify your email address.

You’ve reached your account maximum for followed topics.

Your Rating

Ridley Scott

Fox 2000 Pictures Scott Free Productions Ingenious Film Partners

Reviews (0)

Have You Watched It?

Be the first to leave your review.

Russell Crowe

Albert finney, marion cotillard, abbie cornish, didier bourdon, seasons (4).

Season 1 (2016)

Season 2 (2018), season 3 (2022), season 4 (2026), users reviews (125).

We want to hear from you! Share your opinions in the review below and remember to keep it respectful.

Your comment has not been saved

Related Titles

eternal sunshine of the spotless mind

BABY REINDEER

Notice: All forms on this website are temporarily down for maintenance. You will not be able to complete a form to request information or a resource. We apologize for any inconvenience and will reactivate the forms as soon as possible.

• DVD & Streaming

A Good Year

• Comedy , Drama , Romance

Content Caution

In Theaters

• Russell Crowe as Max Skinner; Albert Finney as Uncle Henry; Freddie Highmore as Young Max; Marion Cotillard as Fanny Chenal; Abbie Cornish as Christie Roberts

Home Release Date

• Ridley Scott

Distributor

• 20th Century Fox

Movie Review

Ethically challenged business gladiator Max Skinner is enjoying the London high life. After all, he’s just led his company’s team of bond traders through a masterful—and legally questionable—financial maneuver that nets his firm millions of dollars. His real friends are few, but he luxuriates in the jealousy of this rivals and the adoration of his underlings. Then he learns that his Uncle Henry, his only living relative, has died at the French chateau and winery where he’s lived for 30 years.

In a series of halcyon flashbacks, we watch a 12-or-so-year-old version of Max spending time with Uncle Henry at the chateau during long visits after the death of Max’s parents. Though he drifted away from the warm and worldly Henry over the years in his quest for financial domination, Max remembers his times at the small winery as the best of his life. Returning now, however, to claim the estate, Max announces his plans to sell the charming place, especially when he realizes the quality of the wine has devolved to the level of vinegar.

At first unmoved by the objections of vine-tender Francis Duflot and his gregarious wife/housekeeper Ludivine—the couple who also cared for the place when Max was a boy—Max speeds his efforts to unload the property when a young woman from America shows up claiming to be Henry’s illegitimate daughter (and possible legal heir). But then Max’s fond memories of his quotable, “good life”-loving Uncle Henry and his newfound affection for a local beauty slowly begin to erode his resolve to leave the Provencal lifestyle behind.

Positive Elements

The film reveals Max’s tendency to cheat his way to success as both unethical and ultimately unsatisfying (though he experiences few actual negative consequences). We learn that Uncle Henry became disappointed in Max’s fixation on making money and winning at all costs. In a flashback, Henry encourages young Max to celebrate his failures as a source of wisdom and to learn to enjoy the simple pleasures of life. Max eventually sees the value in that advice.

Sexual & romantic Content

Part of Max’s big-city lifestyle includes bedding beautiful women. And he questions whether it would be wrong to have sex with Christie, 19, his newfound cousin. A nude woman is very briefly glimpsed in a porn magazine. And many of the film’s females bare cleavage.

When Christie wears a small bikini by the pool and gets a bad sunburn, she allows Max’s eager best friend, Charlie, to treat her by applying ice to her bare back. The camera follows his gaze under her towel as the top of her rear is seen.

At a dinner party, a crude joke is made about sodomy. Max is attracted to local girl Fanny, who lifts her skirt in public to show him a large bruise on her hip and backside. Upon seeing this display, male bystanders applaud. Max and Fanny end up going to bed together. (They partially undress each other.)

Violent Content

In search of comedy, A Good Year includes plenty of pratfalls, mishaps and accidents as Max falls over, through and down various props and bits of landscape. In his car he unknowingly runs a woman on a bicycle off the road while fumbling with his phone. He also falls into a swimming pool, empty expect for manure, and is pummeled by jets of water unleashed to fill it up.

Crude or Profane Language

In addition to a few misuses of the names “Jesus,” “Christ” and “God,” the f-word is heard at least once and the s-word is exclaimed better than a dozen times. The British profanities “bloody,” “b-gger,” “w-nker,” “s-d” and “b-llocks” are heard, as is the sexual euphemism “shag.” “B–tard” and “a–” are also casually tossed around.

Drug and Alcohol Content

Most of the story unfolds at a French winery, and all of the characters drink. In flashbacks, Uncle Henry is seen drinking lots of wine and is known to get drunk. He schools young Max in the ways of winemaking and gives him wine to drink (though he waters it down a little). Older Max regularly drinks harder stuff. At a dinner party, several of the attendees get drunk, including one who can’t quite walk home. Pipes and cigars make appearances.

Other noteworthy Elements

Max, young and old, is a liar and a cheat. As mentioned in “Positive Elements,” that’s mostly cast in a negative light. However, he is seemingly rewarded for his biggest ethical compromise. And even when he chooses to do something noble for his cousin, he needlessly uses deception to accomplish it.

While watching A Good Year , I was reminded just how skillful director Ridley Scott is at crafting heart-pounding action/adventure tales and how adept star Russell Crowe is at creating unforgettably intense and complicated characters. By their bodies of work (which include Kingdom of Heaven, A Beautiful Mind, Gladiator, Black Hawk Down, and Hannibal ), neither strikes you as the kind of a guy who enjoys a lightweight, heartfelt, slapstick-infused romantic comedy. And judging from this effort, they’re not the kind of guys who can make a very good one.

At every moment, you can feel them laboring to create a breezy atmosphere to match the languid beauty of their Provence backdrop. But they just don’t seem to have it in them. Crowe, especially, can’t convincingly dim that famous intensity. His attempts at being a charming, clumsy rascal feel like those of a workaholic dad spending a day off with the kids. Yeah, he’s here goofing around with us, but you can tell his heart is still back at the office emoting about something dark and weighty.

It’s not just Crowe. The storyline is as predictable as a commuter flight on a clear night; you can see that landing strip coming for miles and miles. Moments of dialogue meant to convey profound meaning clunk so loudly I worried folks in the theater next door would be distracted from their film. Then I wondered what they were watching. Then I wanted to go and see.

Thus, I began pondering what A Good Year might have looked like as a straightforward drama about a man forced to reevaluate all his morality-free, self-serving instincts and the life of singular isolation they’ve yielded for him. Throw in one pivotal, rain-soaked action scene, and that’s a movie the Scott/Crowe team could make compelling.

Instead, for the sake of lightheartedness, they lower the stakes to the point where it’s tough to care what choices Crowe’s character makes. The isolated, achievement-driven London high life or the more relational, sensual French country life? Either way, it’s all about what will make Max most happy. Neither choice requires real sacrifice. And that’s the story’s biggest problem. It wants us to see the good life as the one spent soaking up pleasure and community and beauty. Better, maybe, but in the end just a different brand of hedonism apart from selfless service of others.

Will Max ever go searching for deeper meaning outside of himself or will he just repeat his Uncle Henry’s equally empty (though more attractive) life of wine, women and song? Maybe Crowe and Scott can answer that question in an action/adventure sequel.

Christopher Lyon

Latest reviews.

City of Dreams

Weekly Reviews Straight to your Inbox!

Want to stay Plugged In?

Our weekly newsletter will keep you in the loop on the biggest things happening in entertainment and technology. Sign up today, and we’ll send you a chapter from the new Plugged In book, Becoming a Screen-Savvy Family , that focuses on how to implement a “screentime reset” in your family!

a good year (2006)

Your changes have been saved

Email is sent

Email has already been sent

Please verify your email address.

You’ve reached your account maximum for followed topics.

A Good Year (2006)

Oscar-winner Russell Crowe reunites with "Gladiator" director Ridley Scott in A GOOD YEAR, a Fox 2000 Pictures presentation of a Scott Free production. London-based investment expert Max Skinner (Crowe) moves to Provence to sell a small vineyard he has inherited from his late uncle. Max reluctantly settles into what ultimately becomes an intoxicating new chapter in his life, as he comes to realize that life is meant to be savored. A GOOD YEAR is based on the best-selling novel of the same name by Peter Mayle. (Mayle and Ridley Scott, who are longtime friends, together came up with the idea for the novel.) Scott produces from a screenplay by Marc Klein. The film also stars the esteemed Albert Finney as Max's late Uncle Henry, who imparts wisdom to his young nephew; Marion Cotillard ("A Very Long Engagement") as a café owner who catches Max's eye; Abbie Cornish ("Sommersault") as Max's supposed long-lost cousin, who may hold the vineyard's title rights; Tom Hollander ("Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest") as his best friend; and Freddie Highmore ("Finding Neverland") as the young Max. Confident and cocky, headstrong and handsome, Max Skinner is a successful London banker who specializes in trading bonds. A financial barracuda on the banks of the Thames, Max devours the competition in his efforts to conquer the European market. His latest conquest has netted a tidy seven-figure profit, much to the chagrin of his Saville Row-draped rivals. Max's triumph is in perfect keeping with his philosophy: winning isn't everything, it's the only thing! Soon thereafter, Max receives word from France alerting him to sad news: his elderly Uncle Henry has passed away. Max, Henry's closest blood relative, is the sole beneficiary of his estate, which includes a Provençal chateau and vineyard, La Siroque, where Henry cultivated grapes for over thirty years. Max travels to the chateau where he spent his boyhood summers vacationing with his eccentric uncle, whom he hasn't seen or written to in years. While Max tends to the legal affairs of his inheritance, he is suspended from his firm, pending an investigation into his questionable bond transaction. With his future in London in flux, Max reluctantly begins settling into life at the chateau. He reunites with the chateau's longtime vigneron, Francis Duflot (still tending the vines after three decades), whom Max remembers from his boyhood visits. Duflot's exuberant wife, Ludivine, the estate's housekeeper, warmly welcomes Max back. Max is uncertain as to whether life in the South of France suits him. He rings up his best friend, London realtor Charlie Willis, to inquire as to what a small chateau and winery like La Siroque would command on the current market. Charlie advises Max that small wineries with a good product can bring several million dollars, as boutique wine, made in small batches, is the rage in wine shops. It's money in the bank for Max should he lose his job. As Max fondly embraces the memories of summers past (spent with a man whose wisdom and philosophy helped Max chart his successful career) while contemplating a cloudy future, a complication arises with the sudden arrival of a determined, twentysomething California girl, Christie Roberts. Christie, a Napa Valley native, claims to be the illegitimate daughter of the deceased uncle. The revelation, if true, makes her Max's cousin and, according to French law, the beneficiary of La Siroque. Suspecting Christie may be a fraud, Max questions her about her past while bickering with her over the fate of the vineyard, whose plonk (as the French define bad wine) rivals the worst vinegar imaginable. Max, who has tasted La Siroque's awful vin de pays, also finds some other bottles in Uncle Henry's cellar bearing the name Le Coin Perdu ('the lost corner'). This mysterious, legendary vin de garage has fetched thousands per bottle on the black market for years, according to the fetching local cafe owner, Fanny Chenal, with whom Max has become smitten. Where does the wine come from, and why is Duflot so insistent on staying at La Siroque whatever the vineyard's fate? And, what about some unusual vines discovered on the property by Christie, which the crusty vintner claims are experimental in nature, and a renowned oenologue has deemed unworthy? Max's memories and the passage of time bring forth emotions and feelings he thought were long lost, and afford him a new appreciation of his late Uncle Henry's philosophy on life - and on life in Provence: "There's nowhere else in the world where one can keep busy doing so little, yet enjoy it so much!"

Russell Crowe and Ridley Scott Followed Gladiator With a Surprisingly Nice Rom-Com

For their second collaboration, Russell Crowe and Ridley Scott chose something simple and sweet.

Freddie Highmore to Star in Astro Boy

Imagi studios has signed the young actor to voice the boy robot superhero.

THE WEEK IN REVIEW: November 6 - November 12 2006

Recapping the big news of the week - by Brian Gallagher

Russell Crowe Gets Romantic in A Good Year

The actor discusses marriage, working with Ridley Scott, and facing Denzel Washington in next year's American Gangster.

Paramount Pictures to Start Shooting The Spiderwick Chronicles in September

Freddie Highmore and Sarah Bolger star; based on the popular book series.

Setting the Period With Tristan + Isolde Executive Producer Ridley Scott [Exclusive]

Acclaimed director discusses his producing style, A Good Year with Russell Crowe, American Gangster, The Assassination of Jesse James and Shadow Divers.

Marion Cotillard and Tom Hollander Join Ridley Scott's A Good Year

Alongside Russell Crowe in the adaptation of the Peter Mayle novel.

Suggestions

Review: a good year.

The film suggests not so much the stirring of a soul as Sir Ridley grinding his teeth behind the camera.

You know ruthless bond-trader and self-described “asshole” Max Skinner (Russell Crowe) is due for a reminder of life’s simpler pleasures as soon as the steely grays of his London office are contrasted with the honeyed amber of the rural French chateau where he grew up. Such visual obviousness is indicative of the overall laziness of A Good Year , Ridley Scott’s insipid adaptation of Peter Mayle’s novel, filmed apparently for no better reason than to provide cast and crew (but not viewers) with a lush vacation.

Perfectly happy running the “lab rat” co-workers at the office or just reveling in his own smarmy unscrupulousness, Max is summoned to the idyllic cottage of his youth by the death of Uncle Henry (Albert Finney), the once-beloved-but-now-forgotten mentor who, remembered in flashbacks, taught young Max (Freddie Highmore) about life, women, and the “sublime nectar” of wine. Max’s plan is to sell the home and its vineyard pronto so he can go back to screwing rival traders out of millions, but those darn plot contrivances ground him for one week, just enough time for the postcard Frenchness of the provincials to seduce him.

Gallic earthiness is embodied by a shrugging groundskeeper (Didier Bourdon) with a sloppy cap and a pup called Tati, a bubbly housekeeper (Isabelle Candelier) who can’t stop grabbing Max’s ass, and a waitress (Marion Cotillard) with Spunky Love Interest etched on her forehead. The potentially heritage-usurping arrival of a distant Yankee cousin (Abbie Cornish) barely registers in the dramatic radar, since by then the protagonist has already learned to grow a heart, money can’t compete with the forces of nature, it’s the little things in life that matter, yada, yada, yada.

Always a dexterous polisher of surfaces, Scott would seem an appropriate choice to capture touristic images, yet the antic restlessness of the mise-en-scène denies audiences the simple pleasure of looking at the vistas: The high-pressure cutting exposes the filmmaker’s roots in advertising so patently that, when two characters identify themselves by humorously flashing their clothing brands, the wan jest nearly becomes a declaration of guilt. Leaden in its traveloguing, A Good Year suggests not so much the stirring of a soul as Sir Ridley grinding his teeth behind the camera, grimly muttering “I’m going to be breezy if it kills me, goddamit!”

You might be interested in

Sleeping Dogs Review: Russell Crowe Lays It on Thick in Forgettable Memento Clone

Napoleon Review: Ridley Scott’s Epic Wages a Reign of Terror Against Tonal Harmony

Hijack Review: A Bumpy, Intermittently Thrilling, Ride

Fernando F. Croce

Fernando F. Croce is a San Francisco-based film writer whose work has been published in Film Comment , Reverse Shot , MUBI , and Fandor . He runs the website CinePassion .

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Review: The Architect

Review: Curse of the Golden Flower

Sign Up for Our Weekly Newsletter

Get news & reviews in your inbox

• Prime Video
• Documentary
• Producers Corner
• Watch Lists
• More Than A Movie Night
• It’s Dove Approved – Family Movie Trivia Game
• Dove Ratings
• Privacy Policy

A Good Year

Dove review.

“This place doesn’t suit my life. No Max, your life doesn’t suit this place.” That dialog from “A Good Year” sums up the film pretty well. Max (Russell Crowe) is a cruel opportunist, money worshiping, ruthless Englishman. All his good childhood memories take place at his uncle’s vineyard in France and when he returns all he seems to be interested in is the money.

While having an interesting storyline and some fun moments, “A Good Year” is filled with objectionable material for the family in four out of six Dove categories.

Dove Rating Details

Passionate kissing; unmarried couple have sex

F-2; S-14; MG-1; C-4; J-1; OMG-1; B*st*rd-5; H-4; A-5; Sh*g-4 (British slang term)

Lots of drinking, woman gets drunk.

Woman's naked backside shown-2.

Man gives obscene gesture-2

More Information

Film information, dove content.

Faith Film Producer DeVon Franklin Steps in Front of the Camera for ‘Jesus Revolution’

Cyrano: Love is a Verb

Redeeming Love: Grace Rising Up Out of the Dirt

Filmmakers Highlight the Hope and Heroism in “Gi...

Turn autoplay off

Turn autoplay on

Please activate cookies in order to turn autoplay off

• Jump to content [s]
• Jump to site navigation [0]
• Jump to search [4]
• Terms and conditions [8]
• Your activity
• Email subscriptions
• Account details
• Linked services
• Press office
• Guardian Print Centre
• Guardian readers' editor
• Observer readers' editor
• Terms of service
• Privacy policy
• Advertising guide
• Digital archive
• Digital edition
• Guardian Weekly
• Buy Guardian and Observer photos

Today's paper

• Main section
• G2 features
• Comment and debate
• Editorials, letters and corrections
• Other lives
• SocietyGuardian
• Life & style
• Environment

A Good Year

This week's films

Reviews in chronological order (Total 4 reviews)

Unknownusers, submitted by shelly deegan on 01/11/2006 14:23.

11 January 2006 2:23PM

• Recommend? ( 0 )
• Report abuse

Link to this comment:

Submitted by Mr Frost on 02/11/2006 23:17

11 February 2006 11:17PM

Submitted by Stephen Durrant on 03/11/2006 00:32

11 March 2006 12:32AM

Submitted by Rosemary D. on 24/11/2006 00:24

24 November 2006 12:24AM

Today's best video

The week in tv, 'get your arse out, mate', spanish football player's stunning solo goal, whitewater kayaking: 'i wanted to spend every day on the river'.

• Most viewed

Last 24 hours

• 2. The Amazing Spider-Man 2 review
• 3. Quiz: Can you match each of these Bond villains with their own evil plot?
• 4. After Gremlins and The Goonies, what other 80s films need a remake?
• 5. Brendan Gleeson: sins of the fathers
• More most viewed
• 2. Mickey Rooney cuts family out of will
• 3. The Amazing Spider-Man 2 review
• 4. Brendan Gleeson: sins of the fathers
• 5. Cate Blanchett sets her sights on Sutton Hoo drama The Dig
• All today's stories

Film search

Latest reviews.

The Amazing Spider-Man 2 review

Marc Webb's superhero sequel is savvy, punchy and dashing enough to stir the blood of even the most jaded adult, writes Xan Brooks

Noah review – 'a preposterous but endearingly unhinged epic'

The Double review – Richard Ayoade's dark doppelganger drama

Divergent review – lacks lustre and grit

A Story of Children and Film review – Mark Cousins's 'spine-tingling' visual essay

Sponsored feature

• Across the site
• Film reviews
• Film trailers
• Video interviews
• License/buy our content
• Terms & conditions
• Accessibility
• Inside the Guardian blog
• Work for us
• Join our dating site today
• © 2014 Guardian News and Media Limited or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved.

A Good Year (2006): A Romantically Flawed, Predictably Feelgood Film

Film review: a good year (2006).

A Good Year is a British-American dramedy with a good side of romance, produced and directed by Ridley Scott. Russell Crowe stars alongside Albert Finney, Freddie Highmore, Tom Hollander, Abbie Cornish and Marion Cotillard. Indeed, A Good Year has a very good cast.

Set in southern France, in Provence, A Good Year is loosely based on the novel of the same name by Peter Mayle, a neighbour and good friend of the above-mentioned Ridley Scott. Indeed, it was discussions between these two that led to Mayle’s book, which then led to Scott’s film adaptation.

Although billed as a rom-com, A Good Year is truly more of a journey of self-discovery for a man who has lost his way. Max Skinner (Russell Crowe) is a no-holds-barred, sardonic stockbroker who has long forgotten the joyous, little boy he once was. But when forced to return to his childhood haunts in southern France, memories of his boyish self (Freddie Highmore) and the lessons learned from his dearly departed uncle (Albert Finney) begin to surface. Max begins to reevaluate his life and its current trajectory.

When the Boy Becomes the Pirate

There’s a line from the movie Hook , delivered by the always wonderful Dame Maggie Smith, who’s playing the Wendy who grew up, where she looks at the greedy, preoccupied man Peter Pan has become and says, “So, Peter, you’ve become a pirate.” The essence of that line, of childhood innocence lost and grown-up cynicism found, is the essence of A Good Year . The Peter Pan-like joie de vivre of Max Skinner the boy has been replaced with sardonic cynicism and egoism of Max Skinner the man.

The only heir to his estranged uncle’s estate, Max Skinner returns to his uncle’s chateau and vineyard in Provence after many, many years of absence. He’s there to wrap things up as soon as possible, sell the estate, and get back to London and his high-flying career. Max is dashing, arrogant, wickedly witty, superficial in many ways. And yes, he’s an incredibly charming jerk – a real rogue.

RELATED:  ONLY YESTERDAY (1991): A COMING-OF-AGE AND COMING-TO-TERMS GEM OF SUBTLETY AND INTROSPECTION

But the quick stay in Provence suddenly gets prolonged, after Max is suspended for some dubious stock market manipulations. And after the stipulations of the will are a bit more complicated than first thought, especially when a young, American woman (Abbie Cornish) suddenly shows up on the chateau doorstep, saying that Uncle Henry is her dad. And after a certain feisty French café owner (Marion Cotillard) catches the eye of one lonely British stockbroker.

Truly, Max is lonely. That is becoming increasingly clear. The cynicism, the sardonic wit, the sleazy charm is all a front. And the longer he stays in his uncle’s home, the more he remembers the dreaming, wondering boy, he once was. The more he begins to regret his estrangement from the only man who ever truly loved him, his dear uncle. And the more he begins to become his uncle.

In one of the film’s running gags, Max has literally no clothes with him when he came for his quick stopover. So, when the stopover gets prolonged, he finds himself having to raid his uncle’s wardrobe. The designer suits are swapped for ill-fitting old man slacks and sweater vests. It’s an enjoyable transformation, which Max takes in good stride and humor.

And yes, it’s all leading up to a man making a decision about his life, what he wants out of it, and what will make him truly happy in the long run. Can the boy and the man reconcile?

Feelgood Redeemable

There’s a lot to recommend A Good Year . It’s beautifully filmed. Southern France has never been lovelier. The acting is first rate and the chemistry between the cast is palpable. There is so much to dislike about Max Skinner, but you find yourself being charmed by him anyhow. And that says something about Russell Crowe’s portrayal. Max is ultimately a redeemable rogue.

A Good Year is a feelgood film that hits many of the predictable and expected and necessary feelgood points. Where it disappoints though is in the romance department. The romance is too pat, too rushed. I mean, she’s in bed with him lickety-split and he’s not that charming. So, there’s a kind of routinized falseness to that aspect of the story. And it’s this romantic failing which probably aided and abetted the movie’s flopping at the box office. It was and is incorrectly categorized and billed as a romantic comedy. It is not a romantic comedy.

But just because the romance isn’t quite there, it does not mean that A Good Year isn’t worth watching, isn’t redeemable. It is. It’s saccharine and predictable and funny. And did I mention I am a total sucker for tales about grown-ups reconnecting with their inner childhood selves? A Good Year may be romantically flawed, but it does redeem itself in the feelgood department.

RELATED:  THE HUNDRED-FOOT JOURNEY (2014) FILM REVIEW – A BEAUTIFUL EXPLORATION OF CULTURE, FAMILY AND FOOD

Where to Watch: Rent and/or buy on Digital/DVD.

Content Note: Rated PG-13 for language and some sexual content. Swearing in British accents always sounds cute to my ears, but yes, there are more than a few cuss words in the film. Max Skinner is an arrogant cad. There are sexual innuendos. Again, Max Skinner is an arrogant cad. No skin. One brief sex scene, where nothing much is seen.

Have you seen A Good Year ? What are your thoughts on this movie? Let me know in the comments .

Photo Credit: 20 th Century Fox.

OVERALL RATING

“I think this is the beginning of a beautiful

friendship.”

ROMANCE RATING

“Happiness in marriage is entirely a

matter of chance.”

ARE YOU A ROMANCE FAN? FOLLOW THE SILVER PETTICOAT REVIEW:

A lover of words, stories and storytellers since her youth and just plain curious by nature, Jessica embarked on a very long academic journey that took her across a continent (from Canada's west coast to its east) and even to the other side of the globe, where she currently lives an expat existence in Denmark. She now trails many fancy initials behind her name, if she ever cares to use them, and continues to be ever so curious. She's a folklorist, a mother, a wife, a middle child, a small town girl, a beekeeper, an occasional quilter, a jam-maker. She curates museum exhibits, gets involved in many cultural projects for this and that, collects oral histories when she can find the time and continues to love stories in all their many and varied forms. The local librarians all know her by name.

More posts by this author.

Find Family Movies, Movie Ratings and Movie Reviews

A Good Year Parent Guide

Max Skinner (Russell Crow) is having A Good Year in the markets, until he is bequeathed a Chateau in France. Taking time away from the office, the oft-times unscrupulous businessman goes to check out the value of his inheritance. But once surrounded by the castle's charm, the tycoon finds himself toying with the idea of trading in his highlife for a simple, yet poorer, country existence. Unfortunately, viewers will find this sterling premise is tarnished by some content concerns.

Release date November 9, 2006

Run Time: 118 minutes

Get Content Details

The guide to our grades, parent movie review by rod gustafson.

Audiences love to see a grumpy rich guy getting a good lesson on what’s really important, and that’s why movies like A Good Year will be forever popular—no matter how many times we’ve heard the story.

In this telling, a hotshot trader, Max Skinner (Russell Crowe), begins his day dumping bonds and then repurchasing them a few minutes later from the beleaguered market—at a steep discount. The obviously questionable transaction nets him a seven-figure profit, and reinforces his greedy tendencies.

Yet his trip to the Provencal countryside to survey his newfound claim proves to be just the ticket for the hardened business tycoon to take a moment’s pause in his life journey. Although the property turns out to be a bit of a fixer-upper, Max can’t help feeling the charm of the neighborhood or noticing a possible romantic interest in the quaint village up the road. As well, there is a caretaker (Didier Bourdon) who regularly begs him not to sell the property. Max’s uncertainty about what to do with his future only gets worse when he receives news he has been suspended for his earlier trading practices. Suddenly he has even less reason to return to London’s hectic pace.

The usual positive messages about getting life’s priorities straight are evident in abundance in this script. Sadly, so are a collection of profanities, including two uses of a sexual expletive and a finger gesture, along with other crude terms for and conversations about sex.

Artistically, the film does work some magic within the last couple of acts. Max’s recognition of what he chases versus what he really should be reaching for, seem sincere and reasonably believable, especially in a telling scene where his big city boss raves about an original masterpiece he keeps locked in the vault. While the two admire a reproduction of the artwork Max thoughtfully asks, “When do you ever look at the real painting?” The parallel to the protagonist’s life is clear, and sends a valuable message to all of us who keep the best moments of life locked away.

About author

Rod Gustafson

A good year rating & content info.

Why is A Good Year rated PG-13? A Good Year is rated PG-13 by the MPAA for language and some sexual content.

This movie’s heart is in the right place as far as recognizing the importance of relationships and honoring a deceased relative’s wishes. Yet, the protagonist’s choice of the highlife in London versus the peaceful bliss of a French chateau is hardly a difficult dilemma. The moral value of the movie is further overshadowed by a number of sexual expletives and crude terms for sex, which is unusually high for this film’s rating category. An unmarried sexual relationship is heavily implied and discussions about sex, along with a few revealing outfits, are included. A casual attitude toward children drinking wine is portrayed and a young boy pretends to smoke a cigar. A man is slightly injured while attempting some household repairs.

Page last updated July 17, 2017

A Good Year Parents' Guide

The “money can’t buy happiness” premise is frequently played out in movies, yet how does the media industry itself ironically counteract this message? What real people do you know who truly live by this adage? Is this belief one you feel you can or could adhere to?

The most recent home video release of A Good Year movie is February 26, 2007. Here are some details…

DVD Release Date: 27 February 2007

Taste the bouquet of A Good Year with the movies’ release to DVD (in either wide or full screen presentations). Toasting the film is director Ridley Scott’s audio commentary, while the recipe is revealed in The Making of a Good Year . The original theatrical trailer is also provided. Audio tracks are available in English (Dolby Surround 5.1), Spanish (Dolby Digital 2.0 Surround) and French (Dolby Digital 2.0 Surround), with subtitles in English and Spanish.

Related home video titles:

Perhaps the most famous story about a person who reforms his character and turns his love of money into a love of mankind is Charles Dickens’s A Christmas Carol . In Disney’s The Kid , a man changes his priorities after getting in touch with his inner child. The movie Groundhog Day follows a self-centered television personality who is granted (or cursed with) repeated opportunities to figure out the best use of his time and life.

× Do you know these Musicians from their Movies?

A Good Year Movie Reviews

A Good Year Movie Reviews: A Delightful Tale of Love and Redemption

Released in 2006, A Good Year is a romantic comedy-drama film directed by Ridley Scott and based on the novel of the same name by Peter Mayle. Starring Russell Crowe and Marion Cotillard, this heartwarming movie tells the story of a London-based banker, Max Skinner, who inherits a vineyard in Provence, France, and embarks on a journey of self-discovery and love.

Set against the picturesque backdrop of the French countryside, A Good Year offers a delightful cinematic experience that has been well-received by both critics and audiences alike. The film not only showcases the stunning beauty of Provence but also explores themes of love, family, and the importance of finding joy in life’s simple pleasures.

The performances in A Good Year are nothing short of exceptional. Russell Crowe effortlessly brings Max Skinner to life, portraying a successful but disillusioned man who rediscovers his passion for life through the vineyard he inherited. Marion Cotillard shines as Fanny Chenal, a local cafe owner who captures Max’s heart and helps him find the true meaning of happiness. The chemistry between Crowe and Cotillard is palpable, adding depth and authenticity to their characters’ blossoming romance.

Ridley Scott’s direction is masterful, seamlessly blending breathtaking cinematography with a compelling narrative. The film’s visual appeal is stunning, capturing the essence of Provence’s charm and allowing viewers to immerse themselves in its idyllic landscapes. Scott’s skillful storytelling, combined with the beautiful cinematography, creates an enchanting atmosphere that transports the audience to a world of romance and adventure.

The screenplay, written by Marc Klein, successfully adapts Peter Mayle’s novel into a captivating film. The script strikes a perfect balance between humor and heartfelt moments, evoking both laughter and tears from the audience. Its witty dialogue and well-developed characters make for an engaging and emotionally resonant viewing experience.

Now, let’s address some frequently asked questions about A Good Year:

1. Is A Good Year based on a true story? No, the film is not based on a true story. It is an adaptation of Peter Mayle’s novel.

2. Where was A Good Year filmed? The movie was primarily filmed in Provence, France, capturing the region’s stunning beauty.

3. Is A Good Year a romantic comedy? Yes, the film can be categorized as a romantic comedy-drama, as it combines elements of both genres.

4. Who is the director of A Good Year? The film was directed by Ridley Scott, known for his work on films such as Gladiator and Blade Runner.

5. What is the running time of A Good Year? The movie has a running time of approximately 118 minutes.

6. Is A Good Year suitable for all ages? The film is rated PG-13, indicating that it may not be suitable for younger viewers due to some language and adult themes.

7. Did A Good Year receive any awards? While the film didn’t receive major awards, it was well-received by audiences and critics alike.

8. Can I watch A Good Year on streaming platforms? Yes, the film is available on various streaming platforms, such as Amazon Prime and Netflix.

9. Is A Good Year a feel-good movie? Yes, the film’s heartwarming story and delightful characters make it a feel-good movie worth watching.

10. Are there any memorable quotes from A Good Year? One of the memorable quotes from the film is Max Skinner’s reflection on life: “You know, the ancient Egyptians had a beautiful belief about death. When their souls got to the entrance to heaven, the gods asked them two questions. Their answers determined whether they were admitted or not. ‘Have you found joy in your life?’ ‘Has your life brought joy to others?’”

11. Does A Good Year have a happy ending? Without spoiling the plot, A Good Year offers a satisfying and uplifting conclusion that will leave viewers with a smile.

12. Can I visit the vineyard featured in A Good Year? Yes, the vineyard, Château La Canorgue, is a real place in Provence, France, and can be visited by tourists.

13. Is it necessary to read the book before watching the movie? While reading the book may provide additional context and depth to the story, it is not necessary to enjoy the film.

In conclusion, A Good Year is a delightful movie that offers a perfect blend of romance, comedy, and beautiful scenery. With its captivating performances, skillful direction, and heartfelt narrative, the film is a true gem that will warm your heart and leave you with a renewed appreciation for life’s simple pleasures. So grab a glass of wine, sit back, and let A Good Year take you on a journey of love and redemption.

Related Posts

How much paint protection film cost, how to fix vizio tv, the wife meg wolitzer ending, vice president in iron man 3, vertical limit cast, shatter me books in order with novellas, who…books, the magnificent century cast, how to reset vizio tv without remote, maximiliano hernández movies and tv shows, an amish in lifetime, animal planet schedule, where to get a comic book graded, what kind of cat in nine lives movie, the night before full cast, how to write like tolkien, how did yoda die in star wars, the honey pot movie review, the lion the witch and the wardrobe book online, what happened to channel 11 on antenna tv.

‘Beetlejuice Beetlejuice’ Review: Tim Burton’s Lightweight Sequel Works as Ghostly Fan Service

Michael Keaton, Winona Ryder and Jenna Ortega star in a sequel that's no "Beetlejuice," but it's got just enough Burton juice.

By Owen Gleiberman

Owen Gleiberman

Chief Film Critic

• ‘Babygirl’ Review: Nicole Kidman Is Fearless in an Erotic Office Drama About the Age of Control 41 mins ago
• ‘Maria’ Review: Angelina Jolie Is Commanding as Maria Callas in Pablo Larraín’s Lavish but Overly Fatalistic Drama 24 hours ago
• ‘Riefenstahl’ Review: A New Portrait of Leni Riefenstahl Looks Closer at the Question: Was the Filmmaker Complicit in Nazi Crimes? 1 day ago

Back in 1988, “ Beetlejuice ” was a comedy, a ghost story, a high-camp horror film, and a macabre funhouse ride, all driven by a new kind of palm-buzzer freak-show prankishness. I first saw the movie at a Saturday-night sneak preview, before anyone knew a thing about it, and by the time it was over it was clear that the director, Tim Burton , was going to be a superstar who ruled over his own weirdly ardent world of ghoulish mockery.

Related Stories

How Much Should AI Giants Pay Hollywood? What Insiders Say Has Stalled Any Licensing Deals

Spanish Star Paz Vega Joins Venezuelan Thriller 'Death Has No Master,' From Jorge Thielen Armand (EXCLUSIVE)

Popular on variety.

As a result, it’s one of those sequels that spends a lot of time looking back. The film opens with the tingle of Danny Elfman’s jumpy ghost music, along with another flyover shot of the picturesque town of Winter River, Connecticut, where Winona Ryder ’s Lydia Deetz, the former goth teen who interfaced with the spirit world, is now a psychic mediator who hosts her own hunt-for-the-paranormal television show entitled “Ghost House.” Lydia still wears her hair in spiky bangs, but where you might expect her to have relaxed into middle age, the way Ryder plays her she’s more distraught than ever. Maybe that’s because her TV-producer boyfriend, Rory (Justin Theroux), is a fatuous sleaze who speaks in progressive therapeutic bromides to cover his flagrant opportunism. Or maybe it’s because her daughter, Astrid ( Jenna Ortega ), has nothing but contempt for her mother’s ghostly preoccupations, which she thinks are sheer delusion.

Catherine O’Hara, winningly overwrought as ever, is back as Delia, Lydia’s narcissistic artist stepmother. And to spin past any awkwardness over former cast member Jeffrey Jones (who is now a convicted sex offender), his character, Charles — Lydia’s father and Delia’s husband — is given a claymation segment that ends with him being chomped by a shark; the character then spends the rest of the movie skulking through the afterlife as a blood-spurting trunk without a head. As for Keaton’s title pest, he keeps popping up in Lydia’s sightlines, and it’s not long before he’s summoned. Keaton, at 73, invests him with that same obscene gnashing energy and throwaway scuzzball cunning — and, in fact, Beetlejuice figures out another way to coerce Lydia into marrying him. It’s all hooked to the fact that Astrid has fallen for a sweetheart of a dude in her class (Arthur Conti), who turns out to have a very dark secret.

The movie doesn’t come entirely alive until the scene where Beetlejuice, acting as Lydia and Rory’s “couple’s therapist,” literally spills his guts, then produces an infant version of himself — a baby as disquieting as the crawling-on-the-ceiling one in “Trainspotting.” A gambit like this exists mostly for its own agreeably sick sake, and that, in its way, is the “Beetlejuice” aesthetic: Tim Burton making this stuff up simply because it tickles his naughty fancy. At least one thing he has made up is a bit cringe: the punning use of “Soul Train,” complete with a boogie-down chorus line of ’70s funk dancers (which in the movie becomes a train for dead souls — get it?). And the plot has even more of the balsa-wood quality that the Alec Baldwin/Geena Davis ghost plot in “Beetlejuice” had.

Reviewed at Venice Film Festival (Out of competition), Aug. 28, 2024. MPA rating: PG-13. Running time: 104 MIN.

• Production: A Warner Bros. Pictures release, in association with Domain Entertainment, of a Tim Burton, Tommy Harper, Plan B Entertainment, Marc Toberoff production. Producers: Marc Toberoff, Dede Gardner, Jeremy Kleiner, Tommy Harper, Tim Burton. Executive producers: Sara Desmond, Katterli Frauenfelder, Alfred Gough, Miles Millar, Larry Wilson, Laurence Senelick, Brad Pitt.
• Crew: Director: Tim Burton. Screenplay: Alfred Gough, Miles Millar. Camera: Haris Zambarloukos. Editor: Jay Prychidny. Music: Danny Elfman.
• With: Michael Keaton, Winona Ryder, Catherine O’Hara, Jenna Ortega, Justin Theroux, Willem Dafoe, Monica Bellucci, Arthur Conti, Nick Kellington, Santiago Cabrera, Burn Gorman, Danny DeVito.

More from Variety

‘Star Trek: Strange New Worlds’ Cast Teases What’s to Come in Season 3, Why The Season Finale Cliffhanger Was ‘Classic to Trek’

Why Studios Still Haven’t Licensed Movies and TV Shows to Train AI

What’s Coming to Disney+ in September 2024

Disney Fined $36,000 for Fatal Fall on Set of Marvel Series ‘Wonder Man’

Reality TV Survived the ’07 Writers Strike. Why Is It Hurting in 2024?

‘Kraven the Hunter’ New Trailer: Aaron Taylor-Johnson Is Out for Blood in Sony’s R-Rated Marvel Villain Origin Story

More from our brands, eminem and ll cool j team up for first collab ever, ‘murdergram deux’.

We Talked to Diana Vreeland’s Son Freck About Personal Style and His Life as a Spy

Driver in Gaudreau Collision Faces Vehicular Homicide Charges

The Best Loofahs and Body Scrubbers, According to Dermatologists

Knots Landing, Falcon Crest and Sisters Are All Streaming for Free — Find Out Where