○ Needs assessment
○ Study specific aim
○ Global health/local community impact
○
Two successful research projects [ 9 – 11 ] illustrate key concepts of the checklist and will be referred to in the discussion below (Table 2 ).
Case illustrations
Case one: “Pediatric Preparedness of Lebanese Emergency Departments” [ ] | Case two: “Improving triage in a Botswana Emergency Department”. [ , ] |
Study summary: A nationwide survey of all Lebanese hospitals with Emergency Departments (ED) that care for children highlighted that care was provided by a variety of physicians, most without any specific pediatric, pediatric critical care, or pediatric emergency care training. Study checklist key points: • The goal of the principal investigator, RS, was to understand the precarious state of pediatric emergency medicine (PEM) in Lebanon in order to further its development. Specifically, she aimed to describe the EDs of hospitals that cared for children. • A written survey of all Lebanese hospitals with EDs that care for children. • A partnership with an emergency medicine national leader was initially established via relationships that RS already had in place. Discussions between RS and the local partner lead to the specific aim. The participants’ roles in the project were delineated beforehand and authorship credits assigned. The key roles of the local partner included identifying a local research assistant, the wording of the survey in order to facilitate understanding by Lebanese physicians, and helping approach the different hospitals in Lebanon. Culturally, Lebanese respond better to personal contact; therefore, speaking the local languages and establishing and maintaining relationships were key in identifying a local partner as well as recruiting hospitals. • : RS obtained Institutional Review Board (IRB) approval from the US home institution and from the local partners’ institution. • Time and funding were all from personal resources. Study impact: A key result of the study, that unspecialized physicians care for acutely ill and injured children, identified areas for potential intervention. In response to these results, RS partnered with local physicians to create a PEM track in the following Lebanese Emergency Medicine Conference and is now developing a PEM curriculum for the first four-year Emergency Medicine residency program in Lebanon. | Study summary: A quality improvement project team adapted a regionally tested triage system, the South African Triage Scale (SATS) and renamed it the Princess Marina Hospital Accident & Emergency Triage Scale (PATS). Overall, over-triage rates and under-triage rates showed significant improvements, as PATS was more predictive of inpatient admission, Intensive Care Unit admission, and death in the ED than the prior triage system. Study checklist key points: • The Princess Marina Hospital Accident & Emergency (PMH A&E) leadership approached and partnered with the principal investigator, PM, to improve their triage system. • Using the adapted SATS allowed, a SATS team of trainers, that was available in the region, to assist in the training of trainers within the PMH A&E group. • PM spent 2 years in Botswana working with physicians, developing partnerships and gaining familiarity with the local medical system and culture. A memorandum of understanding (MOU) was established between the senior hospital leadership in Botswana and PM’s sponsoring US institution. The role of PM in the project was to travel a few times per year from his home institution to organize the local staff in Botswana to design the project, build up local capacity to continue to manage it, and ensure its sustainability. • All of the data collected and analyzed received approval from the IRBs of PMH, the Botswana Ministry of Health, the University of Botswana, and PM’s US home institution. • PM was able to secure funding for his travel from his home institution, the SATS trainers used their own funds to travel as an investment in their region’s healthcare, and the limited funding required for the rest of the project activities all came from resources within PMH which had a vested interest in improving its triage system and outcomes. Study impact: Developing this adapted triage system (PATS) fostered collaboration between two African countries as well as a US partner, and it promoted higher quality care for children with emergencies at the PMH A&E. This triage system is in year 5 as of 2014. |
As with any sound research project, the first step is defining the research question and objectives. Generally, the project will grow out of personal interests or, preferably in global health, the needs of the local partner. A review of the literature will help identify work already done in the specified field as well as people who have worked in the area of research and the country of interest. Many professional organizations have interest groups to connect with those working in similar areas in global health [ 12 ]. Ideally, in global health settings where the territory and the system may be unfamiliar, the investigator should identify both published and unpublished studies and learn about successes and roadblocks previous investigators faced. Most importantly, the on-site partners must be involved and invited to give feedback on the value and acceptability of the project, and a formal needs assessment can be a valuable tool.
For example, in case one, RS initially aimed to study pre-hospital care but in response to the local partner’s needs, changed to study the emergency department.
Next, the investigator, together with on-site collaborators, should formulate specific objectives from the potential broad research questions. This may be a testable hypothesis, such as a new triage system will have less over-triage than the previous system (case two), or a may be a specific aim describing the training of providers caring for children in local emergency departments (case one).
Finally, the investigator is encouraged to consider the potential impact of the study being planned. These include answers to the following questions: Why is this question worth investigating? What are the potential implications on health outcomes of individual and of the community? Is there a possible impact beyond the population studied? What are the implications for the health resource utilization for the hospital or ministry of health? Will the implementation of this study drain the system or contribute to it?
While any study design may be applied to global health research, the methodology selected will depend on the available data sources, ethical considerations, and resource limitations. A structured planning tool, such as a logic model [ 13 ], will help ensure all necessary resources and desired outputs are considered and will provide a map of the project to share with collaborators. Table 3 lists examples of study designs with special considerations for a global health setting.
Examples of study design: advantages and pitfalls in a global health setting
Study design | Examples | Considerations |
---|---|---|
Experimental designs | Clinical trial Educational intervention Quality/process improvement | • For clinical trials, there must be reasonable uncertainty about whether the intervention or standard of care is better (equipoise) [ ] • Educational and quality improvement projects may allow comparison of the same group before and after • Outcomes from educational interventions can be knowledge, attitudes, or behaviors |
Observational designs [ ] | Prospective cohort Retrospective cohort Case-control Descriptive epidemiology | • Review of existing records from a retrospective cohort or case-control requires reliable clinical or administrative records • Surveys and interview tools should be either validated tools from the published literature or carefully designed and reviewed [ ] • Prospective data collection may require more time and personnel |
Qualitative design [ ] | Interviews | • May generate new ideas for further testing |
Pilot study | Small-size project to assess feasibility | • Identifies potential problems prior to larger-scale study [ ] |
One priority is defining the study population. In a global setting, the local team’s input is invaluable to help understand the population and setting the investigator will be working in and how it will impact the study population.
Finally, the outcome specifies exactly what the study will measure. For example, to evaluate a new triage system, the investigator may want to measure how well the assigned triage level compares to the eventual disposition of the patients (case two). One could also measure staff satisfaction, length of stay, or in-hospital mortality. Using mortality as a measure can potentially show the importance of an intervention, but it can be difficult to demonstrate an impact and may require a larger sample size.
Significant discussion regarding the ethics of research in developing versus developed countries has occurred in recent decades, leading to the elaboration of guidelines specific to research in international settings [ 14 – 16 ]. These highlight the need to consider local cultures, economic capabilities, population needs, the local team’s right to innovation, and self-governance as well as long-term benefits and sustainability to the community studied [ 17 , 18 ].
The principle of respect for persons emphasizes the individual’s right to self-determination and requires protection of those with a lower capacity for self-determination (e.g., children) [ 19 ]. Informed consent is an integral part of this principle and one that often causes complications in research implementation. For instance, in some societies, it is traditional and acceptable for the husband or another male relative to make decisions for a woman [ 14 ]. In others, the consent of community elders or senior family members must be sought before individual consent is obtained, if it is to be obtained at all [ 15 ]. Finally, illiteracy and cultural perceptions of western medicine may prove to be significant barriers to obtaining informed consent [ 20 ]. Discussions with local partners early on will be invaluable in understanding cultural implications of the proposed study and adjusting study design accordingly.
The principle of beneficence centers on non-maleficence and maximizing benefits while minimizing risk [ 19 ]. One controversy arising from the implementation of this principle for research in developing countries is the question of “standard of care,” i.e., should research studies in developing countries be required to provide the best available therapies (often standard of care in developed countries) as controls or should the standard of care in the local setting (frequently no or minimal therapy) be used? Such dilemmas have occurred frequently in published literature [ 20 – 22 ].
The principle of justice is exemplified by fairness of distribution. It requires appropriate selection of subjects and requires that the population in which the research study is being performed directly reap the benefits of the study [ 19 ]. Case 2 illustrates this principle: in Botswana, the host hospital was left with a new triage system uniquely designed specifically for it [ 10 , 11 ].
To protect research subjects and follow the basic ethical principles outlined above, there is a requirement that proposed research studies be reviewed by independent bodies based on ethical merit and scientific validity [ 14 , 15 ]. In principle, research should be held to high standards regardless of location. Generally, studies in developing countries involving cross-national collaborations require review by Institutional Review Boards (IRBs) (or Research Ethics Committees) in both the developed and developing countries [ 14 ]. Identifying IRBs in developing countries may be difficult. If not available at the host institution, IRBs may be available at nearby large educational institutions/universities. In addition, local or national Ministries of Health could provide such services. Finally, if after a good faith effort to locate an IRB, but one does not exist at all in the country of interest, guidelines exist to assist in establishing one specifically for the study in question (Table 4 ).
Institutional review board resources
Office for Human Research Protection (OHRP) [ ] Institutional Review Board Guidebook [ ] Institutional Review Board Identification: Office for Human Research Protections (OHRP) Database for Registered IORGs & IRBs, Approved FWAs, and Documents Received in Last 60 Days [ ] |
Culture is pervasive in life, impacting every aspect of human behavior. The undertaking of a project in a different country where language, customs, religion, economic, and political climates all vary requires significant preparation [ 23 ]. A transparent relationship with a focus on humility and respect for the local partner’s culture is essential [ 24 ]. Sometimes, even a well thought out project may be affected by an unanticipated cultural misunderstanding [ 25 – 29 ].
In case one, RS had a rich understanding of the local culture given that she had lived there for many years. In creating the hospital surveys, since Arabic and English are the two languages utilized by most physicians, the team decided not to translate the survey in French, another main language in Lebanon. It was during the analysis that the word “resident” was noted to mean “someone who works in the hospital” for the physicians not trained in the US (or similar) medical system. This underscores the fact that even when a researcher has extensive knowledge about a culture, he or she may be from a different social class, ethnicity, or religion and therefore have a different understanding on certain issues and may not be aware of all the cultural variations within one nation.
In another unpublished example by LM, a project investigating the understanding of child abuse in Ghana was unsuccessful in getting local IRB approval because it was deemed to be too sensitive a topic with too many cultural implications for the local community.
Partnerships with local institutions, hospitals, or academic facilities are a necessary foundation to successful global health research projects. In creating a global health project, ideally, the first priority is to identify a local partner or institution that will serve as the “Local Champion” for the proposed project. This is often done over time, building a partnership individually or with a group. This long-term partnership is key to success as evidenced in the above-illustrated cases. Secondly, the project should be mutually beneficial to all parties involved and the identified partner should be equally committed and interested in the research project. In case two, the local team approached PM, highlighting their need and commitment. In academic settings, identifying partner priorities for research and offering authorship roles can be a motivating factor. Finally, delineating clear roles and expectations of both partners involved through memorandums of agreement/understanding (MOA/MOU) (Fig. 1 ) will provide concrete guidance for the project partnership. This could include responsibilities such as funding, housing, teaching, and authorship. Ideally, if these three key concepts are present then a successful partnership and a global health project are feasible [ 8 , 30 – 32 ]. Table 5 presents priorities and pitfalls in creating durable and productive partnerships.
Example of a memorandum of understanding
Priorities and pitfalls in creating durable and productive partnerships
Priorities | Pitfalls |
---|---|
Mutual benefit | Not understanding partner priorities or imposing external priorities |
Mutual investment/involvement | Not engaging key stakeholders as a voice in the “decision making” process |
Identify funding and mobilization of resources | Wasting recipient hospital or country resources |
Minimize inequity | Unilateral interest |
Find a local champion | Not understanding or identifying unique barriers to specific champions and/or research in partnering countries |
Promote local ownership | “One size fits all mentality” |
Partner capacity building | Sustainability of programs or projects |
Relationship building | Lack of trust and transparency in partnerships |
Understanding the political and legal landscape | Not discussing these issues with local partner and institution |
The successful completion of an international project depends largely on logistical planning of timelines, budget, implementation, and manuscript publishing.
Timelines should include time for local partner identification, study design and development, data collection, and manuscript writing and submission. Careful planning should account for differing cultures and potential delays, such as availability of local partners and obtaining local IRB approval.
Expenses should be projected early in the project and funding options explored. Oftentimes, the pilot study may have to be funded by personal means. However, a partial list of potential funding agencies for clinicians is available in Table 6 . Recently, Hansoti et al. described the potential funding opportunities available specifically for emergency medicine physicians working in international settings. This paper helps the reader navigate the complicated world of grants from seed to federal grants [ 33 ]. In addition, gaining the support of the principal investigator’s home institution can be critical in funding time and travel expenses, as well as finding home institution global research funds.
Global Health Research Funding opportunities for clinicians
American Academic of Pediatrics, Section on International Child Health (SOICH) [ ] Fogarty International Clinical Research Scholars & Fellow Program Support Center [ ] USAID Global Health Fellows II [ ] Fogarty International Center: • NIH funding opportunities [ ] • Non-NIH funding opportunities for faculty [ ] Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. Grant opportunities [ ] Grand Challenges in Global Health. Grant opportunities [ ] Pivot™ [ ] National Science Foundation. Active funding opportunities [ ] Office of International Affairs. Global Health Initiative––funding [ ] Grand challenges in global health. Rewarding innovative ideas [ ] Center for global health. The University of Chicago. Funding agencies for global health opportunities [ ] American Nurses Association. Opportunities for research funding [ ] |
In planning for project implementation, health and safety travel preparedness should not be ignored. Research trip requirements can be found by visiting the public domains of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention [ 34 ], the World Health Organization [ 35 ], the home country’s embassy website in the partner country as well as the partnering country’s embassy websites. Planning for the visiting members of the team with clear roles and check-in mechanisms is critical for both the safety and functionality of the team.
First, this checklist is limited by the fact that it is focused on clinicians and may not benefit other researchers involved in global health research such as public health providers. However, this is a deliberate choice, as it is a gap in the published literature and based on our prior experience an invaluable tool for our clinician colleagues.
Moreover, this checklist requires validation, which we will be undertaking.
We have delineated a comprehensive Global Health Research Checklist for clinicians , consisting of five sections that we have deemed necessary for a successful project. We believe that the checklist presented above is a valuable tool to plan and assess the feasibility of global health research projects. We have highlighted specific areas a clinician researcher should address when embarking on a global health research project. Figure 2 reproduces the checklist with specific questions to be used by the clinician researcher. Having developed this checklist based on experience and currently available literature, our future aim is to validate it.
Personal checklist
Not applicable.
Authors’ contributions.
RS generated the idea and contributed to the study design, literature search, figures, writing, editing, group organization, and submission of the manuscript. KB and OBK contributed to the study design, literature search, figures, writing, and editing of the manuscript. RS, LM, and PM contributed their case studies based on their research work. EA, JC, DG, LM, and PM all contributed equally to the study design, literature search, figures, and writing of the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Consent for publication, competing interests.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
The work in this manuscript, The Global Health Research Checklist for physicians, has been formally presented at a workshop at the Pediatric Academic Society, on May 4, 2013, in Washington, DC.
Rasha D. Sawaya, Phone: (+961) 71529297, Email: bl.ude.bua@931sr .
Kristen A. Breslin, Email: gro.lanoitansnerdlihc@nilserbk .
Eiman Abdulrahman, Email: gro.lanoitansnerdlihc@arludbaE .
Jennifer I. Chapman, Email: gro.lanoitansnerdlihc@nampahcJ .
Dafina M. Good, Email: gro.lanoitansnerdlihc@doogD .
Lili Moran, Email: moc.liamg@nanabiliL .
Paul C. Mullan, Email: [email protected] .
Oluwakemi Badaki-Makun, Email: ude.imhj@2ikadabO .
The following resources are links to external sites that offer country analyses.
Many financial firms produce reports on doing business in a variety of countries. These reports typically aren't easy to find, so be sure to read the descriptive text under each link for instructions on how to locate the reports.
Related documents.
You can add this document to your study collection(s)
You can add this document to your saved list
(For complaints, use another form )
Input it if you want to receive answer
Country Research Project Handout |
---|
> > |
---|
|
---|
Here is a fun and simple fact sheet for researching an individual country. Students are asked to name the country and its inhabitants (such as "Norwegians" for Norway), then list the country's language(s), capital city, currency, population, religion(s, important rivers and lakes, things the country makes and grows, and three interesting facts about the country. On the back of this sheet, students are instructed to draw a map. Click to print. |
---|
All materials on this website are © www.studenthandouts.com unless otherwise noted. Please contact us via Facebook or Twitter with any questions. - - - - |
Note: Product links are paid affiliate links. All links are deemed relevant and are not placed merely for profit. Purchase through these links helps to keep this educational website online and free. |
Wednesday, february 25, 2015, country research project.
1. Choose a country. |
2. Begin your research. |
3. Use the to guide you in your project. |
4. After completing your research you will write a research paper. |
5. You also need to include a picture of your country's flag. |
6. You need a picture of one major landform in your country. |
7. You need to include a map of your country. |
Post a comment.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.
Resource type.
COMMENTS
Your paper should have an INTRODUCTION which includes: The name of the country. The capital of the country. The major language (s) spoken. The location (what continent it's on) Your paper should have at least one paragraph discussing the HISTORY of your country which includes: The Date the country came into existence.
What is a country research project? In simple terms, as part of social studies, students create a report on a country by researching facts about it. Their country report could be a wide range of presentation mediums such as a written project, an oral presentation, a poster, worksheets, a performance or even a video, you can be as creative as you like! Student can use a range of methods to ...
Use the RESEARCH CHECKLIST to guide you in your project. 4. After completing your research you will write a research paper. 3-5 pages long. Written in a 12-point font. 5. You also need to include a picture of your country's flag. 6. You need a picture of one major landform in your country.
Our Country Research Project is ideal for older elementary students and middle school students. Before tackling this Country Research Project, we introduce, review, and solidify basic map skills with our FREE Printable World Maps & Activities.
*The name of the country *Capital *Population *Languages spoken *The location (what continent it's on) Economy Climate Interesting Facts *Natural Resources *Goods Produced *Major occupations (jobs) *The currency (type of money) *2 pictures *General weather conditions *Average yearly rainfall *Average yearly temperature *What effects the climate ...
Prepare the Room for Research Projects. world map to hang or project on a screen. world atlas - online or book. globe - physical or virtual. make it a festive environment with world flags decor. country map (s) - posters or printed. posters of famous landmarks, people, inventions, etc. vocabulary wall.
Completing a country research project is a great way to open your students eyes to different countries, cultures and people of the world.
Country Research Activities Country research projects can be a powerful tool for helping students understand the diversity of cultures and the world around them. This type of project offers a unique opportunity for students to immerse themselves in another culture, learn about different customs and traditions, and broaden their perspectives. To make sure that your students are enjoying the ...
Spanish - Country Project. Learning a new language is not just about being able to speak it, but also immersing yourself in other cultures. This project will allow students to explore all aspects of life in other parts of the world and will help them develop research skills. This is a multi-faceted project that teaches a variety of skills ...
Country Research: Home The Government Information Library is your gateway to information about foreign countries. This guide provides a rich selection of online resources on countries, regions, and territories throughout the globe.
With this inquiry project, students will be encouraged to use their decision-making skills to craft questions and make learning choices. Teachers can easily monitor students' progress and provide opportunities for advice through conferencing. To enhance their map skills, students must correctly illustrate and label the country/location of ...
For this assignment, students choose a country to study and create a project to showcase their learning. This resource guides students through conducting their own research report on a country of the world (75 topics are listed). After choosing a country to focus on, students are asked to conduct research using the Internet and books while ...
Country Research Project - 100% Editable 1 Rating View Preview Grade Levels 5th - 10th, Homeschool Subjects Social Studies - History, Geography Resource Type Research, Projects Formats Included Zip Pages 18 pages $4.76 List Price: $5.95 You Save: $1.19 Add one to cart Buy licenses to share Add to Wish List Share this resource Report this resource to TpT Creative Lab 1.1k Followers Follow ...
Introduction:This project will test your research skills, your critical thinking skills, and give you an opportunity to do what we all would like to do: rule your own country. It is pretty darn important for you to keep this packet handy, since it contains all the information you need to complete this project.
This bundle includes: 1) A country research note taking handout, with 14 questions/key points students should take notes on when researching countries (to increase their global awareness) 2) A project checklist, with a rubric, for students to make a poster 3) A parent letter (to sign up for food; a...
This Global Health Research Checklist was developed to be used by clinicians or other health professionals for developing, implementing, and completing a successful research project in an international and often low-resource setting. It consists of five sections: Objective, Methodology, Institutional Review Board and Ethics, Culture and ...
This guide lists books, databases and websites on country research including country financial risk resources, exchange rates and an extensive list of "doing business in…" country guides. General research tips are also provided.
1. Choose a country. Get it approved by Ms. Liu by October 3 rd. 2. Begin your research. Take all of your notes in your writing composition book. Your research must be completed by October 17th. 3. Use the research checklist to guide you in your project. 4. After completing your research you will write a research paper.
A BEST SELLER! Have students create a country with this activities pack! A fun end of the year project and a great way to review geography and map skills all at the same time! Students can use the country checklists and organizers to guide them as they work on creating their own country project.With...
Country Research Project Handout. Here is a fun and simple fact sheet for researching an individual country. Students are asked to name the country and its inhabitants (such as "Norwegians" for Norway), then list the country's language (s), capital city, currency, population, religion (s, important rivers and lakes, things the country makes and ...
Get started for FREE Continue. Prezi. The Science; Conversational Presenting; For Business
DRAFT Research and Development Centers Checklist 10 G4 Support center staff and students to attend national and international meetings if they will make substantive, center-related ... research Revisit projects as a basis for rationalizing and developing an unwarranted defensive posture about their shortcomings I5 Maintain high
1. Choose a country. 2. Begin your research. 3. Use the research checklist to guide you in your project. 4. After completing your research you will write a research paper. Your paper should be: 3-5 pages long. Typed (12-point font) OR written in blue/black ink; Double Spaced; 5. You also need to include a picture of your country's flag. 6.
PROJECT CHECKLIST Will your research be performed in a laboratory? General Safety is a multi-disciplinary approach to developing and ensuring safe work practices, maintaining the health and well-being of employees, and ensuring compliance with regulatory agencies.
Country Research Projects: This newly revised (July 2023) country study worksheet packet will help your 4th grade, 5th grade, and 6th grade social studies students conduct a country study research project for countries around the world.
Ali Vaez, Iran project director at the International Crisis Group, said in a November email: "China significantly reduced its imports from Iran from around 800,000 barrels per day in 2018 to ...